Thanksgiving Dinner Soup: One Controversial Pea Away from Perfection!
Jeff
11/17/20266 min read


How the heck do we follow up last week's historic soup in a SpudBowl™? Ahhh, how about a Thanksgiving Dinner Soup!
This one was inspired by my uncles when I was a kid. As I recall, and I'm guessing this happened at plenty of other family Thanksgiving dinners, everyone would start off with their individual food items sitting in their own happy little places on the plate. Turkey here, mashed potatoes there, stuffing in the corner, cranberry sauce minding its own business. A beautiful, organized Thanksgiving dinner! But within minutes, it looked like a tornado had ripped through the plate! Everything was mixed together into one giant pile of Thanksgiving goodness. I often found myself following suit. And you know what? It tasted even better that way!
So, naturally, I got to thinking...can we soup this? Better yet, can we make it whole-food, plant-based (WFPB) and still capture that incredible Thanksgiving dinner flavor profile?
Now, a word of caution to our Campbell's Crew™ members. This is not a soup build for the novice! Surgeon Jenn and I spent over three hours of nonstop souping to pull this masterpiece together. And that doesn't even include the time it took to smoke an entire turkey! Yes, folks, this was a serious culinary undertaking. There were potatoes flying, vegetables chopping, pots boiling over, and enough ingredients spread across the kitchen to feed a small army. At one point, I think we had more going on than the actual Thanksgiving dinner we're trying to recreate!
So, what exactly have we created? Well, let me introduce you to Thanksgiving dinner in a bowl!
We're starting with a mashed potato and sweet potato Bottomer™, followed by a souper healthy broth base that somehow tastes like Thanksgiving gravy! Then come the homemade sourdough starter crackers, seasoned to deliver that classic stuffing flavor. On top of that, we're adding a sweet cranberry and walnut topper to complement the savory crackers. And for our meat-loving Soup Clubbers, we're finishing things off with some finely diced smoked turkey!
Mashed potatoes, sweet potatoes, gravy, stuffing, cranberry sauce, and turkey. All the Thanksgiving classics, without needing six different serving dishes or an uncle to mix everything together!
And the early results? Let's just say the sample bowls were hearty, delicious, and disappeared pretty darn fast! Kevin and Hunter already got a sneak preview, and the reviews were outstanding.
I hate to sound overconfident here, but this thing is practically screaming for Soup Club's first perfect score! And get this, Kevin...without hot sauce!
Of course, we've still got Conlan's chunkage requirements, Felton's meat expectations, and whatever other surprises our Soup Clubbers decide to throw at us. But I'm feeling pretty darn good about this one!
Let's see what they think!
Soup Club Feedback:
Kevin: Slapped his sticky note on the table and announced, "No notes, ten!" Wait, that's it? No hot sauce? No complaints? No suggestions for improvement? Just a straight-up 10.0? I almost fell out of my chair! Coming from Kevin, that's about as good as it gets!
Conlan: When Conlan starts his review with "Absolutely phenomenal," you know something special is happening! He went on about how delicious the tart cranberry was and how perfectly it paired with everything else. Then, before we could get into a lengthy discussion about chunkage, he dropped a 10.0! Could this be Conlan's first perfect 10.0 in Soup Club history? I'm not sure, but I'm certainly not going to question it!
Josephene: And here we go...you knew someone was going to find something! Remember, Josephene doesn't like corn in soup. Well, apparently, this corn was crunchy, so that was acceptable. But then we got to the peas. She doesn't like peas. Period. So, naturally, she gave the soup a 9.0. Wait a minute! She then admitted that these particular peas were actually good! So, does that bump the score to a 10.0? Apparently not. No comment. I'll take the 9.0, Josephene, but I'm filing a formal protest with the Soup Club scoring committee!
Tam: "This soup was delicious...just like Thanksgiving dinner!" And then she dropped a 10.5! Now, normally I'd have to step in and remind everyone that our scoring system only goes to 10.0. But after the whole Josephene corn-and-pea situation, I decided to let this one slide. A 10.5 it is! Thanks, Tam!
Adam: I really should have recorded Adam's review. The guy launched into a full-blown soliloquy, starting with how I described the Thanksgiving Dinner Soup concept last week. Then he went on a beautiful rant about how I absolutely knocked it out of the park! He was so impressed that he actually started worrying this soup might ruin his family's Thanksgiving dinner. How's he supposed to sit down to a traditional Thanksgiving meal after experiencing this masterpiece? That's a legitimate concern, Adam! A perfect 10.0!
Marketing Mike: No call, no show. That's it. No soup, no score, no explanation. Somewhere out there, Marketing Mike is missing one hell of a Thanksgiving dinner!
Soup Club Average: 9.9!
Campbell's Crew™:
Felton: A perfect 10.0! Loved every drop! Wait, what? No complaints about the meat? No request for a can of Spam? Apparently, the smoked turkey did its job! We may have finally cracked the Felton code!
Hunter: "Thanksgiving in a bowl!" A perfect 10.0! Short, sweet, and exactly what we were going for. But then things got a little strange. Hunter grabbed one of the pumpkin oat cookies, stuffed it in his pocket, and walked away. Huh? Was he saving it for later? Taking it home for further analysis?
Marco: Marco started by saying this could be the best soup I've ever made! Well, except for the pineapple fajita soup. Oh, and the pizza soup. So, apparently, it's somewhere in the top three! He loved the crackers, thought the smoked turkey was fantastic, and said the consistency was perfect. A 10.0! Thanks, Marco! I'll take a spot on the podium any day!
Barry: Barry said he would actually get in his car and drive somewhere to buy this soup! Now that's a compliment! Not just "I'd eat it again," but "I'd burn gas and spend money to get it!" He hit it with a hard 10.0! Thanks, Barry!
Nick: Hearty and delicious! A perfect 10.0! Sometimes you don't need a ten-minute speech to get your point across. Thanks, Nick!
Chris (CSR): A perfect 10.0, although he wasn't crazy about the meat. Wait, what? We finally get Felton to stop complaining about the lack of meat, and now someone doesn't like the meat? You just can't win with these people! But hey, a 10.0 is a 10.0!
Chris (Sales): 10.0! No lengthy explanation needed. Apparently, the soup did all the talking!
Jacob: "Perfectly balanced!" A perfect 10.0!
Campbell's Crew™ Average: 10.0!
So, how'd we do following up last week's historic SpudBowl™ debut? Pretty effin good, if I do say so myself!
A 9.9 from Soup Club and a perfect 10.0 from Campbell's Crew™! Are you kidding me? We were one controversial pea away from perfection! And technically, if we let Tam's 10.5 cancel out Josephene's 9.0...well, never mind. I'm not going to start manipulating the numbers. Although the thought did cross my mind!
Seriously, this was my best Soup Club offering to date, and I couldn't be happier with how it turned out. I've had some pretty decent scores with partner soups over the years, but nothing quite like this at Soup Club. Surgeon Jenn and I put a ton of time and effort into creating something different, healthy, and delicious, and seeing everyone enjoy it made those three-plus hours in the kitchen worth every minute!
Who would have thought you could take an entire Thanksgiving dinner, turn it into soup, make the base whole-food, plant-based, and nearly pull off a perfect score? And without a single drop of hot sauce! I'm calling that a Thanksgiving miracle!
Next week...Kevin! Now, normally Kevin has his soup planned out weeks in advance. The guy usually knows exactly what he's bringing, how he's making it, and probably what kind of hot sauce he's going to dump into it. But as of today? Apparently, he doesn't have a clue!
After back-to-back historic Soup Club meetings, the pressure is officially on! Will Kevin rise to the occasion? Will he bring something completely unexpected? Will there be chicken? Hot sauce? Both?
Stay tuned, Soup Clubbers! The soup train keeps rolling, and things are getting souper interesting around here!










